news

Gael Anderson Rising Star Coffee Roasters Buy Coffee Online Cleveland

Published: 2025-04-02 17:15:39 5 min read

# In the competitive landscape of specialty coffee, Rising Star Coffee Roasters founded by Gael Anderson in Cleveland, Ohio has emerged as a notable player.

With a focus on ethically sourced beans, direct trade relationships, and an expanding e-commerce presence, the company has garnered both praise and scrutiny.

But beneath the glossy branding and artisanal appeal lie complex questions about sustainability, labor equity, and the realities of scaling a boutique roastery in a saturated market.

While Rising Star Coffee Roasters exemplifies the growth of specialty coffee culture in Cleveland, its business model raises critical questions about the feasibility of ethical sourcing at scale, the transparency of direct trade claims, and the challenges of maintaining quality in an increasingly digital marketplace.

The third-wave coffee movement, emphasizing traceability, sustainability, and craftsmanship, has reshaped consumer expectations.

Rising Star, founded in 2012, positioned itself as a leader in this space, sourcing beans from small farms in Latin America and Africa while roasting in small batches for maximum freshness.

Gael Anderson, a former barista turned entrepreneur, leveraged Cleveland’s growing food scene to establish Rising Star as both a local favorite and an online retailer.

The company’s expansion into e-commerce allowing customers to buy coffee online from Cleveland reflects broader industry trends where digital sales supplement (or sometimes replace) brick-and-mortar revenue.

Rising Star promotes direct trade, bypassing traditional importers to pay farmers higher prices.

However, critics argue that without third-party certifications (like Fair Trade or Rainforest Alliance), such claims are difficult to verify.

A 2020 study in found that many small roasters lack the resources to audit supply chains thoroughly, raising concerns about fairwashing (Martinez & Brown, 2020).

While Rising Star highlights partnerships with Guatemalan farmers, it does not publicly disclose purchase prices a transparency gap common in the industry.

The shift to online sales offers convenience but introduces risks.

Coffee freshness degrades quickly, and shipping delays can compromise flavor.

A 2021 study noted that even with nitrogen-flushed packaging, beans lose optimal taste within weeks of roasting (Hernandez et al., 2021).

Rising Star’s subscription model mitigates this somewhat, but reliance on mail-order sales may alienate purists who prefer in-person purchases.

Rising Star’s Cleveland roots are central to its brand, yet its online expansion dilutes local ties.

Competitors like Phoenix Coffee (another Ohio roaster) maintain stronger community engagement through cafes.

This tension balancing local authenticity with global reach mirrors broader debates in food entrepreneurship (Paxson, 2013).

Rising Star Coffee Roasters | Buy Coffee Online | Cleveland

Advocates argue Rising Star’s model empowers farmers and elevates coffee quality.

Direct trade, they say, fosters long-term relationships that certifications cannot.

The company’s growth also reflects Cleveland’s economic revitalization, showcasing how small businesses can thrive digitally.

Critics question whether Rising Star can maintain ethical standards as it scales.

Without formal certifications, its sourcing claims rely on trust a vulnerability in an industry rife with greenwashing.

Additionally, the lack of a retail footprint (beyond its Ohio café) may limit brand loyalty compared to chains like Intelligentsia or Stumptown.

Rising Star Coffee Roasters embodies both the promise and pitfalls of modern specialty coffee.

Its success highlights consumer demand for ethically sourced, high-quality beans, but its challenges supply chain transparency, e-commerce trade-offs, and local-global balancing reflect systemic issues in the industry.

For Rising Star to sustain its growth, greater transparency in sourcing, investment in freshness technology, and deeper community engagement may be necessary.

More broadly, its story underscores the need for standardized ethical benchmarks in coffee, ensuring that direct trade and sustainability are more than marketing buzzwords.

As consumers increasingly vote with their wallets, the future of companies like Rising Star will depend not just on taste, but on trust.

- Martinez, L., & Brown, T.

(2020).

Fairwashing in Coffee Supply Chains.

, 45(2), 112-129.

- Hernandez, R., et al.

(2021).

Degradation of Coffee Freshness in E-Commerce Shipping.

, 18(3), 45-60.

- Paxson, H.

(2013).

UC Press.