entertainment

Ellie Kills Abby - The Last Of Us 2 Alternate Ending - YouTube

Published: 2025-04-21 03:42:46 5 min read

The Ghosts of Our Choices: Deconstructing the Ellie Kills Abby Last of Us Part II Fan Edit Evidence and Analysis: The fan edits generally replace the final confrontation's climax, showcasing Ellie delivering a fatal blow to Abby.

These versions typically receive overwhelmingly positive comments on YouTube, often framed in terms of justice being served and a restoration of narrative satisfaction.

The comments section becomes a microcosm of the broader discourse surrounding TLOU2, highlighting the audience’s desire for a clear-cut narrative resolution reflecting a traditional, albeit simplistic, morality.

The lack of ambiguity in these edits caters to a viewer expectation of direct retribution, ignoring the inherent ambiguity presented in the original narrative.

This preference for a clean ending speaks to a certain expectation within action-adventure narratives, particularly within a revenge-driven plot.

However, deviates intentionally from this formula.

As noted by [insert relevant academic source on video game narratives and player expectations], players often struggle with narratives that subvert their expectations of clear-cut good versus evil, heroic triumphs, and satisfying conclusions.

The fan edits represent a direct attempt to recapture that sense of satisfying closure.

Different Perspectives: Proponents of the fan edits claim the original ending is unsatisfying, robbing the player of a sense of closure and undermining Ellie's agency.

They argue the game prioritizes message over storytelling, resulting in a narrative that feels morally ambiguous and intellectually dishonest.

Conversely, critics of these edits contend they fundamentally misunderstand the game's core message: the futility and devastating consequences of endless cycles of revenge.

They argue that the original ending, while emotionally challenging, is a more thematically resonant and ultimately more impactful narrative choice.